Insight | Regulated Financial Services

Leadership Transition Exposure

Why the First Eighteen Months Decide the Mandate

A new chief executive or managing director inherits more than a strategy. With the role come the decision habits of the previous mandate: who really approves what, which issues always go to the top, which priorities have been waiting for years. Across the Caribbean, at least 11 of the 37 banks and trust companies I reviewed in November 2026 had appointed a new chief executive or managing director since the start of 2024, or had announced one for January 2027.

Leadership transition exposure is the period in which those inherited habits are either reset or harden into the new leader's operating reality. It is short, and it is the cheapest moment the institution will have to change how it decides.

The New Leader Inherits the Old Decisions

The appointment is announced, the regulator approves, the handover is planned. What is rarely handed over explicitly is how decisions are actually made. Informal authority sits with the people who have been there longest. Some approvals go to the top out of habit rather than need. Priorities from the previous strategy are still open, half funded and owned by nobody in particular.

In the first months, everyone expects change, and change costs little. Teams wait to see what the new leader will decide. After a year or so, the waiting stops. Whatever the new leader has not changed becomes their operating model, whether they chose it or not.

At a Glance

11 of 37 Caribbean banks and trust companies with a new CEO or MD since 2024, or one announced for January 2027 Own review, November 2026 +3.6 pts Excess annual TRS when new CEOs of underperforming firms made 4+ strategic moves in two years (vs +0.4 for others) McKinsey Quarterly, 2016 CEO The forcing function in every bank McKinsey has seen move AI from pilot to production at scale McKinsey, Global Banking Annual Review 2026


Where the Exposure Shows Up

In regulated financial services, transition exposure tends to appear in five places:

  • Inherited escalation: decisions that went to the previous chief executive keep coming to the new one, including many that should be decided two levels below.
  • Informal authority: long-serving managers keep a veto nobody wrote down, and new priorities slow down when they reach them.
  • Stalled priorities: initiatives from the previous strategy stay open, consuming budget and attention without a clear decision to continue or stop.
  • The leadership team: members wait for signals rather than act, and differences in how they see priorities stay hidden.
  • The board: it judges the new leader on results that still reflect the previous mandate, with no baseline to tell the two apart.

None of these appears in the handover documents. All of them shape what the new leader can achieve.



Why It Is Consistently Underestimated<

Leadership transitions are prepared as appointments: search, selection, approval, announcement. The first months are then spent learning the business and meeting clients, staff and regulators. Resetting how decisions are made rarely appears in the onboarding plan.

Research on new chief executives points the other way. In a study of nearly 600 CEOs, McKinsey found that what leaders do in their first two years matters: at companies that had been performing poorly, new CEOs who made four or more strategic moves in that period achieved on average 3.6 percentage points of excess annual total returns to shareholders over their tenure, against 0.4 for their less bold counterparts. The authors' advice is to make a few bold moves early and to adopt an outsider's mindset.

In banking, McKinsey's 2026 Global Banking Annual Review adds that every bank it has seen move from pilot to production at scale with AI "has done it with the CEO as the forcing function and a senior leader personally responsible for driving adoption". A new leader who spends the first year absorbing inherited habits has less force left for that.



Using the Window

The transition window cannot be extended, but it can be used deliberately. Four steps make the difference:

  • Measure before you change. An independent baseline of decision ownership, escalation and follow-through in the first months shows which habits the new leader inherited, before they become their own.
  • Decide what stops. Review the open priorities from the previous mandate and take an explicit decision on each: continue, change or close.
  • Reset the escalation load. Return routine decisions to the level where they belong, so the new leader's time goes to the few decisions only they can take.
  • Give the board a reference point. Running the same assessment again after twelve to eighteen months shows the board what has changed under the new leadership, separately from results inherited from the previous one.

The Execution Resilience Diagnostic™ provides that baseline, for one leader or a whole leadership team. Where it shows a structural issue, a Decision Rights Reset of four to six weeks resets authority limits and escalation paths early in the mandate.



Conclusion: Reset Early, While Change Is Expected

A leadership transition is judged on the day of the appointment and, eighteen months later, on whether the institution decides any differently. The difference between the two is how the window was used.

New leaders who put decision rights on their first agenda, not on the list for when they know the business, keep the freedom the transition gave them. For more on execution resilience in Caribbean financial services, see the overview.



Sources:

  • Own review of public information on 37 banks and trust companies across eight Caribbean jurisdictions, November 2026 (see the overview).
  • McKinsey & Company, Michael Birshan, Thomas Meakin and Kurt Strovink, How new CEOs can boost their odds of success, McKinsey Quarterly, 2016 (strategic moves of nearly 600 CEOs in their first two years; at poorly performing companies, four or more moves linked to 3.6 percentage points of excess annual TRS, against 0.4 for less bold counterparts). Source
  • McKinsey & Company, Akshay Kapoor, Brian Ledbetter, Jonathan Leydon, Klaus Dallerup, Marti Riba, Saptarshi Ganguly, Sid Tiwari, Teresa Diviu and Vik Sohoni, Global Banking Annual Review 2026: The AI disruption dividend, November 2026 (every bank that moved from pilot to production at scale did so with the CEO as the forcing function). Source